The efficacy of recommended treatments for veterans with PTSD : A metaregression analysis

Soldiers and veterans diagnosed with PTSD benefit less from psychotherapy than nonmilitary populations. The current meta-analysis identified treatment predictors for traumatised soldiers and veterans, using data from studies examining guideline recommended interventions, namely: EMDR, exposure, cognitive, cognitive restructuring, cognitive processing, trauma-focused cognitive behavioural, and stress management therapies. A systematic search identified 57 eligible studies reporting on 69 treated samples. Exposure therapy and cognitive processing therapy were more effective than EMDR and stress management therapy. Group-only therapy formats performed worse compared with individual-only formats, or a combination of both formats. After controlling for study design variables, EMDR no longer negatively predicted treatment outcome. The number of traumafocused sessions, unlike the total number of psychotherapy sessions, positively predicted treatment outcome. We found a relationship between PTSD pretreatment severity levels and treatment outcome, indicating lower treatment gains at low and high PTSD severity levels compared with moderate severity levels. Demographic variables did not influence treatment outcome. Consequently, soldiers and veterans are best served using exposure interventions to target PTSD. Our results did not support a group-only therapy format. Recommended interventions appear less effective at relatively low and high patient PTSD severity levels. Future high-quality studies are needed to determine the efficacy of EMDR.



Geachte bezoeker,

De informatie die u nu opvraagt, kan door psychotraumanet niet aan u worden getoond. Dit kan verschillende redenen hebben, waarvan (bescherming van het) auteursrecht de meeste voorkomende is. Wanneer het mogelijk is om u door te verwijzen naar de bron van deze informatie, dan ziet u hier onder een link naar die plek.

Als er geen link staat, kunt u contact opnemen met de bibliotheek, die u verder op weg kan helpen.

Met vriendelijke groet,
Het psychotraumanet-team.


Reference: 
Joris F.G. Haagen, Geert E. Smid, Jeroen W. Knipscheer, Rolf J. Kleber | 2015
In: Clinical Psychology Review = ISSN 0272-7358 | 40 | august | 184-194
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272735815000987
Keywords: 
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Cognitive Processing Therapy, Cognitive Restructuring, Effectiveness, Evidence Based Treatment, Interventions, Meta Analysis, Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, Psychotherapy, PTSD (DSM-5), PTSD (DSM-III), PTSD (DSM-III-R), PTSD (DSM-IV), PTSD (ICD-10), PTSD (ICD-11), PTSD (ICD-9), Trauma Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Treatment, Veterans